Close

What are you looking for?

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Why is smartthings apparently designed by *****?

(Topic created on: 02-02-2025 05:43 PM)
348 Views
Dasyurid
Explorer
Options
Ok so bit of a rant about how smartthings is just utterly stupid in its design when it comes to setting up households etc. I recently decided to start using the smartthings app as I had bought some smarttag2's and I need the app to track them etc. Anyway after looking around I saw some features in there I liked and decided to use the app for more than just tracking the tags. It is at this point I immediately had issues as part of this decision meant setting up my household which is logical and all well and good until you want to add people to your household. Why is it that every member of my household in order to be part of my household has to set up their own household? This is the most stupid design idea and concept I have come across after Google making all children admins on the Google home platform! The idea behind this decision is apparently so an individual can add items to their smart things without them automatically being shared with the entire household. Surely a more logical less confusing way is to simply allow the member to select if the item is a whole household item or personal item at the point of connection. For example of I add a light or washing machine to the household devices I can select that it is a household item and when I add a headset I can say no don't share with the household add this as a personal item and make it only available to me. I ask this as with everyone having household items the constant switching to my wife's household or my kids household to turn devices off or on is just ridiculous and so against the concept of smart it boggles the mind that anyone on the apps design team still has a job there beyond mopping the office block floors! How hard could it be to just make an app that is genuinely smart and intuitive unlike the haphazard mess that is smartthings as it stands?
0 Likes
2 REPLIES 2
Ginsing64
Troubleshooter
Options
Like everything today someone else, tells you how things should be used and who can do what. These phones are supposed to be able to be personalised the way you want them.
0 Likes
Dasyurid
Explorer
Options
Yeah I get that about personification of your device but with regards to the household set up in the smartthings app it is utterly insane that everybody has to set up a household and then be added to another household and to view the household you have to swap into another's household even though you are all in the same physical house. My wife and 3 daughters have to go through the rigmarole of swapping into my household in order to turn lights on in smartthings and it is ridiculous. I know people have personal devices within a household but why not just set one household and allow each user to set what is their own personal devices that are not to be shared? It is just something that is actually stunningly stupid especially if certain people in the household are children! Google screwed up on the issue also making it so the children need parental permissions set by a parent but somehow are automatically added as admins with absolute control over every device in the house including smart locks that I bought literally so I could exclude kids from the workshop so they don't have accidents with power tools etc or get hold of my archery bow or my air rifle I use for target shooting! Unbelievable how messy and incompetently designed these apps are as though those designing them have no idea what they are actually doing or what a household is and what makes one up.
0 Likes