Close

What are you looking for?

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Is photo post processing cheating ?

(Topic created on: 04-01-2025 02:15 PM)
153 Views
Obsydian
Samsung Members Star ★
Options

If AI is a threat, what about all the existing photo editing tools?

Photo editing with tools like Lightroom or Snapseed isn't considered cheating; it's a creative process to enhance and refine an image. Most photographers use post-processing to adjust lighting, colours, or composition, aligning the final result with their artistic vision.

So is this not cheating and if we are to watermark AI altered content, surely the same should apply to any other editing software.

What do you think?

 

2 Decades Samsung Ownership, If my response helps leave a Like and Accept as a Solution
DAILY: ZFold6, Watch Ultra, Fit3, CL Ace 2, BT-W6, 20,000 Power bank, Smart Tags
FAMILY: ZFlip5, ZFlip6, Watch6 Classic, Tab S8 Ultra, Tab S7 Plus, Buds Pro2, Buds3 Pro
OFFICE: Book2 Pro i7, M70A 32”, Logitech K700, MX Ego, M720 Triathlon, Pop, Jabra Evolve2
AV/GAMING: QN95A 50” TV, Q900A, SW900s, 8 Series TV, LG OLED, M70A 43”, Dell Inspiron G5
APPLIANCES: Jet 75 Vacuum, MC32 Oven, American Fridge, 8 Series TV, LG OLED
SPARES: ZFlip4, ZFlip3, Buds1 Pro, Buds2 Pro, Book2 Pro i5, Level Speaker
MAINTAIN: iPhone 14, iPad Air4, iPad Mini4, iPad Pro1 12.9, Watch6

17 REPLIES 17
lminvti
Samsung Members Star ★
Options
Personally, I think only AI generated content should have a watermark on it, as AI is getting so good sometimes without AI watermark. You would question if this is real or AI.

Photo editing isn't cheating as we adjusting things to look pictures a bit better without AI.
Ashutosh0603
Pathfinder
Options
I think it's everywhere even if taken with dslr we still need to process it manually to get an optimizated picture soo it's actually good in my pov that samsung does it for us then we doing it ourselves 😋😋
Obsydian
Samsung Members Star ★
Options

I was talking with someone today, they spend ages with desktop apps, yes they look good, but he took the bait and I called him a cheater, 3 seconds of photo and 30 minutes editing 🤣

It's no longer authentic 

2 Decades Samsung Ownership, If my response helps leave a Like and Accept as a Solution
DAILY: ZFold6, Watch Ultra, Fit3, CL Ace 2, BT-W6, 20,000 Power bank, Smart Tags
FAMILY: ZFlip5, ZFlip6, Watch6 Classic, Tab S8 Ultra, Tab S7 Plus, Buds Pro2, Buds3 Pro
OFFICE: Book2 Pro i7, M70A 32”, Logitech K700, MX Ego, M720 Triathlon, Pop, Jabra Evolve2
AV/GAMING: QN95A 50” TV, Q900A, SW900s, 8 Series TV, LG OLED, M70A 43”, Dell Inspiron G5
APPLIANCES: Jet 75 Vacuum, MC32 Oven, American Fridge, 8 Series TV, LG OLED
SPARES: ZFlip4, ZFlip3, Buds1 Pro, Buds2 Pro, Book2 Pro i5, Level Speaker
MAINTAIN: iPhone 14, iPad Air4, iPad Mini4, iPad Pro1 12.9, Watch6

0 Likes
Obsydian
Samsung Members Star ★
Options

I like your answer, but I'm too lazy to bother with post-processing or be clueless.

Are the photos equal, Point shoot, Post Processed, AI Remastered ?

2 Decades Samsung Ownership, If my response helps leave a Like and Accept as a Solution
DAILY: ZFold6, Watch Ultra, Fit3, CL Ace 2, BT-W6, 20,000 Power bank, Smart Tags
FAMILY: ZFlip5, ZFlip6, Watch6 Classic, Tab S8 Ultra, Tab S7 Plus, Buds Pro2, Buds3 Pro
OFFICE: Book2 Pro i7, M70A 32”, Logitech K700, MX Ego, M720 Triathlon, Pop, Jabra Evolve2
AV/GAMING: QN95A 50” TV, Q900A, SW900s, 8 Series TV, LG OLED, M70A 43”, Dell Inspiron G5
APPLIANCES: Jet 75 Vacuum, MC32 Oven, American Fridge, 8 Series TV, LG OLED
SPARES: ZFlip4, ZFlip3, Buds1 Pro, Buds2 Pro, Book2 Pro i5, Level Speaker
MAINTAIN: iPhone 14, iPad Air4, iPad Mini4, iPad Pro1 12.9, Watch6

Ashutosh0603
Pathfinder
Options
Ummm, I have taken Bunch of photos on samsung I have used tools to process in the gallery app itself and when I try to remaster it, it says that remastering is not required. Soo I think AI knows how a photo could look best. Ofcourse the photo taken raw and post process are different coz u can change it to your liking. Let's say I don't like my face it's too round I can change my jawline in app to make it look better 😅😂😂😂 well just lil processing and it looks good to go🤭
-Robot-
Samsung Members Star ★
Options
I don't think post processing is an issue, we don't always capture the photo prefectly, so a little post editing is ok

I don't really use AI except to clean up a photo or remove objects and people
Obsydian
Samsung Members Star ★
Options

Just a little ...

2 Decades Samsung Ownership, If my response helps leave a Like and Accept as a Solution
DAILY: ZFold6, Watch Ultra, Fit3, CL Ace 2, BT-W6, 20,000 Power bank, Smart Tags
FAMILY: ZFlip5, ZFlip6, Watch6 Classic, Tab S8 Ultra, Tab S7 Plus, Buds Pro2, Buds3 Pro
OFFICE: Book2 Pro i7, M70A 32”, Logitech K700, MX Ego, M720 Triathlon, Pop, Jabra Evolve2
AV/GAMING: QN95A 50” TV, Q900A, SW900s, 8 Series TV, LG OLED, M70A 43”, Dell Inspiron G5
APPLIANCES: Jet 75 Vacuum, MC32 Oven, American Fridge, 8 Series TV, LG OLED
SPARES: ZFlip4, ZFlip3, Buds1 Pro, Buds2 Pro, Book2 Pro i5, Level Speaker
MAINTAIN: iPhone 14, iPad Air4, iPad Mini4, iPad Pro1 12.9, Watch6

0 Likes
Sonora
Black Belt 
Options

But that is cheating too, it's not original picture 

Obsydian
Samsung Members Star ★
Options

We have them now, can't call AI tweaks cheating and then say "I just tweak for 15 mins to bling the photo".

 

C H E A T E R S

2 Decades Samsung Ownership, If my response helps leave a Like and Accept as a Solution
DAILY: ZFold6, Watch Ultra, Fit3, CL Ace 2, BT-W6, 20,000 Power bank, Smart Tags
FAMILY: ZFlip5, ZFlip6, Watch6 Classic, Tab S8 Ultra, Tab S7 Plus, Buds Pro2, Buds3 Pro
OFFICE: Book2 Pro i7, M70A 32”, Logitech K700, MX Ego, M720 Triathlon, Pop, Jabra Evolve2
AV/GAMING: QN95A 50” TV, Q900A, SW900s, 8 Series TV, LG OLED, M70A 43”, Dell Inspiron G5
APPLIANCES: Jet 75 Vacuum, MC32 Oven, American Fridge, 8 Series TV, LG OLED
SPARES: ZFlip4, ZFlip3, Buds1 Pro, Buds2 Pro, Book2 Pro i5, Level Speaker
MAINTAIN: iPhone 14, iPad Air4, iPad Mini4, iPad Pro1 12.9, Watch6