Close

What are you looking for?

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Original topic:

Forum Moderation

(Topic created on: 28-06-2023 07:12 AM)
Obsydian
Big Cheese
Options
Can the site moderators share the basics of who, how posts are flagged and removed, I regularly see with post I follow get an NAR and as mentioned in another post my comments dissappeared with a tell tale NAR.
Regards, Obsydian

DAILY DEVICES
ZFold4 [Mobile], Pro5 [Watch], S8 Ultra [Tablet], Book2 Pro i5 5G [Laptop], Buds Pro2 [Buds] M70A 32/43" [Monitor], Smart Tags+, iPad Mini 5 and iPad Pro 12.9 GEN2 [Tablets], Dell Inspiron G5 Laptop

HOUSEHOLD DEVICES
ZFlip3 and ZFlip4 [Mobile], Watch5 40mm and 46mm [Watch], S7+ and S6 Lite [Tablet], QN95A [TV], Q900A [Soundbar], MC28M6075 and MC32K7055 [Microwave], Jet 75 Complete (Vaccum), Samsung Level [Speaker], Buds Pro [Buds], iPhone 12, iPad Air 2, Air tags
6 REPLIES 6
nowdeleted
Big Cheese
Options
Nar means no action required. So depending on what you have commented about its the moderators decide on what action has been decided.
I had 4 nars last week , no idea for what. But its keeps them happy.
AntS
Moderator
Moderator
Options

Hi @Obsydian ,

 

We remove stuff that goes against the Members Community TOS (https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/news-rules-faqs/community-terms-of-service/m-p/92#M1 ) & Guidelines (https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/news-rules-faqs/community-guidelines/m-p/97#M2 , duplicates, or at user request for their own post(s) to be removed.

 

 

Regarding the 'NAR': There’s a bug in the Members app build that mistakenly notifies standard users to replies we make of clones of their posts in our moderator area (which standard users don’t have access to - hence the confusing messaging of them being deleted). Those post clones are for our review, and automatically generated by any instances of keywords that the management wanted to make sure we didn’t miss. The ‘NAR’ tells the rest of the team that it’s been reviewed by a moderator and ‘No (Further) Action Required' on that specific instance (e.g. it’s a false flag; just a reply to a topic with one of the keywords in the topic title; or already been dealt with). 

 

It's been going on a while:

 

https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/samsung-lounge/andrewl/m-p/7218028#M17333

https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/samsung-lounge/can-t-view-item-original-post-deleted/m-p/5969667...

https://eu.community.samsung.com/t5/news-rules-faqs/acronyms-used-by-moderators-in-post-report-feedb...

 

We reported the bug back in 2020, and have kept on reporting it since, but apparently it’s proven to be difficult for the various people at the Samsung side of things to fully resolve.

Obsydian
Big Cheese
Options
But no notice is given if something is removed ?
It's just removed ?
Regards, Obsydian

DAILY DEVICES
ZFold4 [Mobile], Pro5 [Watch], S8 Ultra [Tablet], Book2 Pro i5 5G [Laptop], Buds Pro2 [Buds] M70A 32/43" [Monitor], Smart Tags+, iPad Mini 5 and iPad Pro 12.9 GEN2 [Tablets], Dell Inspiron G5 Laptop

HOUSEHOLD DEVICES
ZFlip3 and ZFlip4 [Mobile], Watch5 40mm and 46mm [Watch], S7+ and S6 Lite [Tablet], QN95A [TV], Q900A [Soundbar], MC28M6075 and MC32K7055 [Microwave], Jet 75 Complete (Vaccum), Samsung Level [Speaker], Buds Pro [Buds], iPhone 12, iPad Air 2, Air tags
0 Likes
Obsydian
Big Cheese
Options
I'd rather not bother with such a forum.
Regards, Obsydian

DAILY DEVICES
ZFold4 [Mobile], Pro5 [Watch], S8 Ultra [Tablet], Book2 Pro i5 5G [Laptop], Buds Pro2 [Buds] M70A 32/43" [Monitor], Smart Tags+, iPad Mini 5 and iPad Pro 12.9 GEN2 [Tablets], Dell Inspiron G5 Laptop

HOUSEHOLD DEVICES
ZFlip3 and ZFlip4 [Mobile], Watch5 40mm and 46mm [Watch], S7+ and S6 Lite [Tablet], QN95A [TV], Q900A [Soundbar], MC28M6075 and MC32K7055 [Microwave], Jet 75 Complete (Vaccum), Samsung Level [Speaker], Buds Pro [Buds], iPhone 12, iPad Air 2, Air tags
0 Likes
BandOfBrothers
Samsung Members Star ★★
Options

@Obsydian 

These comments you create > are they comments made on another person's thread as replies ?

If so and there has been moderation implemented on another person's thread to remove content that infringes the Community Guidelines then it maybe the case your reply comments then bear no relevance due to the previous moderation.

So to keep a thread on topic and within guidelines they'll need to keep the thread straight.

The Community I assume has hundreds of posts and threads created per day so making contact with individual members wouldn't possibly be possible.

Just my thoughts on this.


Daily Driver > Samsung Galaxy s²³ Ultra 512Gb in Phantom Black.

The advice I offer is my own and does not represent Samsung’s position.
I'm here to help. " This is the way. "

AntS
Moderator
Moderator
Options

Cheers BandOfBrothers. 👍

 

@Obsydian , We try to give notice whenever we can: either by a public post in the relevant topic or by PM (depends on what’s appropriate to the situation). Exceptions are duplicate topics/posts, and spam/advertising topics/posts from the various bots and chancers we frequently get on here (replies to those spam/advertising posts tend to get swept up in the clean-up operation).

 

Duplicates are pretty obvious (and if there are replies to duplicate topics we merge the topics and remove/edit the duplicate posts in order to keep coherence as best we can). And the spam/advertising too much of to keep posting notices of (you'd have multiple posts and variations of "Hey, you know that user you thought was genuine? Well, it turns out they were a fake, with a fake problem or fake advice, and just wanting to sneakily post a 'hidden' link to a site selling fishing equipment or pirated apps.")

 

And of course, there's good old fashioned human error on our part: where someone should've been notified their post was removed, and why, but just wasn't in that instance. 

 

I'm happy to have a look into any posts of yours you reckon are missing. Can you remember what they were about and roughly when they were posted?

0 Likes