@Graykenhill Do you get anything when you double tap the AOD clock? I was seeing just the settings cog. I tapped that and unlocked, then turned off auto-brightness. Now when I double tap the AOD clock I see the cog and the brightness icon - tapping that icon once gives me the slider to adjust brightness.
Just in case this helps, the options for the Always on Display that I use are:
Mon, 25 November
-Show music information: On
-Rotate screen to: Portrait
-Auto brightness: off
@Graykenhill Have you sent feedback about it on the Members app?
I've just tried every clock style and the cog/brightness icon appeared on all of them even the calendar and image ones.
The only one it was missing from was the edge clock, but I expected that as it says widgets and notifications won't display.