28-07-2021 09:25 AM - last edited 28-07-2021 11:04 AM
I have been using an eSIM and a SIM together for a while now. This morning I received a message from my provider where I currently have a physical SIM that I can switch to eSIM. So, that's what I did, but after removing my physical SIM I noticed that I cannot activate two eSIMS at the time.
Why is this? What is the point of the eSIM if you can't even activate multiple eSIMS simultaneously? Or do I have something not configured right?
I am using the Note 20 Ultra.
28-07-2021 11:09 AM in
28-07-2021 11:34 AM - last edited 28-07-2021 11:35 AM
28-07-2021 12:21 PM in
Well, I don't see the point if you can only have one eSIM. If you could have at least two eSIMs active simultaneously it would make sense because manufacturers could eventually remove the SIM tray.
But with the limitation that you can only have one eSIM you still need the SIM tray, and you still need to transfer that one physical SIM to another phone.
Only allowing one eSIM active at the time feels like a half baked implementation to me.
Of course, not everyone has multiple SIMs, but for someone like me who lives in two countries it is a must have.
18-09-2021 11:42 AM in
Having only 1 esim active is definitely half baked implementation. One other thing that I don’t like with esims is that you can’t migrate the esim when you change phone.
08-02-2022 11:42 PM in
Migrating an esim to another phone is possible, network provider permitting. Some allow it by simply redownloading the esim through the apps, others make it more difficult or at times even impossible without visiting a physical store.
15-04-2023 01:19 PM in
If Pixel can do it, there's no reason why Samsung couldn't do it.
I live in 2 countries and have had OnePlus'es for ages which sport a dual SIM tray.
Just got Z Fold 4 and made my primary SIM go e. I am also traveling quite a bit, so I thought this is handy!!
I can have both post paid as eSIMs and then use a physical prepaid when travelling in different countries for data. Pretty soon discovered that only one eSIM can be used at a time which was a HUGE disappointment from Samsung which should be a leader in this industry.
Hopefully, this is something that can be enabled/fixed with software update.
3 weeks ago
I work for an MVNO. An eSIM is not purely a software SIM, it's an Embedded SIM, IE, it's a microchip included on the device itself, pretty similar to a normal SIM, that has the ability to switch profiles. Asking why you can't enable more than one eSIM at a time is like asking why one physical SIM card isn't two SIM cards, it just doesn't have the capability to run two profiles at the same time. This is not a 'half baked' solution, it's an Embedded SIM solution. To get around this the manufacturer would need to include two or more eSIM chips on the device, given the limited use case for this it's unlikely that manufacturers would incur the additional cost.
I can't really think of a use case for more than two active cellular connections on a device at a time, however having the ability to switch between up to 20 installed eSIM profiles seems like overkill but should satisfy even the busiest traveler.
The 'hassle' of switching between profiles if you are travelling is not worth the additional cost and power consumption to include additional eSIM chips on the device.
3 weeks ago
Ok, thanks for the clarification. I'm still thinking whether it would be possible to achieve with one chip. I remember from my time with Nokia, when some chearper dual sim models had only one radio, which was used in turn by both SIMs which effectively simulated 2 SIMs working at the same time.
You can speak on you on behalf, but as an expat who travels a lot, I practically would preferably have the SIM from my home country and the country of residence on at the same time. And then occasianally a SIM card of the country I am visiting. Especially when so many ***** services use SMS verification etc.