Ricky, I foolishly assumed that the watch Samsung health would also update!
Have figured I'm kind of stuck with this for now but wouldn't buy another Samsung watch, which is such as shame as most everything else on it is great
Well this guy giving his 48hr review of the Galaxy Watch, he complains about the HR but not the flat-line (Might not know of the issues) but you can see in the video the Galaxy Watch still has some flat-lines. I guess this is a good thing for people that are stuck with the old watches as it might mean if people complain about this on thier new watches samsung might be forced to fix it and the update might come to the older models too.
Also Desfit is reviewing the watch atm, if anyone has a youtube account a message with link to this thread and info about the issue had on the old models would be good for him to know about. I find his reviews of sports watchs great and if he runs into this issue on the watch it would get the word out.
Anyone knows if we use GEAR TRACK app, will work in GEAR SPORT, correctly?
Because, my heart rate is totally wrong in S.Health.
Do you think that the problem is really the software?
If you look back through previous posts we've basically proved this is a software issue with the Samsung Health app itself on the watch.
Yes using the gear tracker app works with the gear sport watch. For me it fixes the problem 100% of the time.
I've not got time at the moment to go through all the troubleshooting which has been done to prove the app is the problem. Have a look back through the previous comments.
Desfit has run into HR issues on the Galaxy Watch, not sure it's the same as the Gear S3/Sport but I don't have a youtube account to message him this thread, he said he is trying to reach out for comment so him knowing this is an ongoing issue would be great pressure on Samsung and he can mention in his review of the Galaxy Watch they have not fixed the issue that has being going on for months.
Just had a look on youtube at anouther reviewers video of the new galaxy watch. He has some likes and dislikes after 48hours of use, he mentions a disapproval of the HR but only that it does a random jump to 200bpm. He doesnt mention the flat lineing although when hes showing the 200bpm on his phones shealth app, you can see his HR graph and if you look at my screenshot, you can clearly see flat lines still present during his running activity for his HR. This therefore must be a software issue and not hardware considering the galaxy watch is definately new and runs with different hardware. I cant believe ssmsung havent sorted this? If it helps samsung, the Gear S2 works perfectly everytime with the HR graph.
Any updates mods?
I wrote the Gear Tracker App. I've seen issues with HR since Tizen 3. The reason Gear Tracker works continuously is that I detect the HR API lock up and restart the sensor after 30secs. I also have issues with high readings. I've also noticed on my Gear S3 since the recent update the issues have worsened for me. Check out my posts at https://facebook.com/GearTrackerApp
I have had an open ticket with the Samsung Developer Program on this for several months now and have been continually updating it with ongoing issues, and info from other posts and users like here. I've actually had a response from support showing their own test results and confirming they were able to reproduce the issue on Tizen 188.8.131.52! They've also stated that this info has been forwarded to the HR team for review. I'll keep pushing for a response.
As far as I'm concerned this is a software issue as it worked fine under tizen 2.3.2. I beleive that Samsung are so focused on saving battery usage that everything else comes second and gets overlooked.
As a developer it's a very challenging working on this platform.
Finally, I'm continuously looking into ways to overcome or fix these issues, hopefully one day soon Samsung will sort this out.
Thank you so much for that response.
It's about time we had some backend information about this issue.
So far we've been doing troubleshooting directly from the front end but we can only see so much.
Glad you came across from Facebook to look at this thread! Thanks for your efforts.